Can 3D Printing of Alternative Proteins Take Off?
Regular readers will be familiar with Gartner’s Hype Cycle for emerging technologies, which graphically represents the ups and downs that most new technologies undergo, as they move from the “that’s super cool” stage to “what’s it good for” stage to “here’s how we can actually make money” stage. We often refer to the Hype Cycle in articles about 3D printing – a technology with great potential but mixed results so far. 3D printing stocks, for example, continue to struggle, while some companies are finding success in on-demand manufacturing. Metal 3D printing, in particular, is showing signs that it can compete with traditional manufacturing. On the other hand, there are some applications that seem heavy on the hype, like 3D food printing. We’ve recently come across an even more niche 3D printing food category that is riding an even trendier market: alternative proteins.
The switch from animal products to foods that mimic meat and dairy has snowballed in the last few years, driven by concerns over climate change, human health, and animal welfare. That has led companies to cook up all sorts of alternative proteins, from growing single-cell proteins that feed on methane to fermenting dairy proteins with genetically modified yeast to producing real burgers or seafood from animal cells in a lab. Now a small handful of companies are turning to 3D printing for making alternative proteins.
3D Printing Plant-based Alternative Proteins
More specifically, several startups have emerged within the last year that are focused on 3D printing plant-based alternative proteins. The most well-funded of the bunch is an Israeli company founded last year called Redefine Meat (formerly known as Jet-Eat). The Tel Aviv-based startup just raised $6 million in September for its 3D printing technology that aims to reproduce the taste, texture, and appearance of meat while using a combination of three vegetable proteins, along with plant-based fat and other ingredients. The company says that 3D printing allows it to control the production process much more precisely, especially compared to the off-the-shelf 3D printers used by other food companies.
It hopes to roll out its semi-industrial 3D printers by 2020, marketing the machines to supermarkets for consumers and meat distributors for restaurants.
NovaMeat out of Barcelona, Spain, also popped onto the scene in 2018 and raised money last month, though no word on the actual funding amount. However, there are more details about the company’s 3D printing technique for plant-based meats from its Italian founder, Giuseppe Scionti, who developed the technology based on his research in bioprinting synthetic tissues for artificial ears and other body parts. The 3D printer is able to arrange the nanofibers of plant proteins like pea powder and seaweed to replicate the structure and texture of either steak or chicken. The 3D printer itself was developed by a technology center that is part of Scionti’s university, according to an article in 3Dnatives.
The printer extrudes a paste onto a printing plate using a design that Scionti created on CAD software. The price point is currently about $3 per 100 grams, which works out to about $13.50 per pound.
A third startup, also out of Israel, that has been called variably SavorEat and Chef-it, has yet to officially launch, as far as we can tell. The company’s 3D printing technology is based on the research of Hebrew University professors Oded Shoseyov and Ido Braslavsky. The former is a serial entrepreneur who has reportedly started about a dozen different companies, many around his discoveries on nanocellulose, a strong plant-based fiber that can be used in applications as diverse as clothing and medical implants. The 3D printing platform would use nanocellulose as the binder to create all sorts of plant-based dishes that could be printed and cooked layer by layer. As Shoseyov said in a 2018 interview, “You could make a plant-based burger with fries in the middle. I’m talking about things that are not possible with regular cooking methods.” The last we heard, the nascent company was attempting to raise at least $2 million to get off the ground.
3D Printing Animal-Based Alternative Proteins
More established alternative protein companies are also turning to 3D printing technology. Yet another Israeli company, Aleph Farms, recently made headlines for 3D printing meat in space. Founded in 2017, Aleph has raised $14.4 million, including a $12 million Series A in May that involved food giant Cargill. The startup is part of the growing cohort of companies growing real meat from animal cells, and it expects to have the first lab-grown steak in limited markets in just a couple of years. The company went even further this month by announcing it had 3D printed a small piece of cow muscle tissue on the International Space Station in collaboration with a company called 3D Bioprinting Solutions.
Space.com reported that the experiment involved using a bioprinter that is equipped with a magnetic force that aggregates the cells into one small-scaled tissue that one could conceivably call meat. We’ll stick with Tang for now.
We first introduced you to Irish startup Perfect Day almost two years ago. It has raised about $61.5 million to date for creating dairy products without cows by genetically modifying yeast cells to produce casein and whey, the main proteins in milk. The company uses a special 3D printer to insert parts of a cow’s modified DNA into specific locations in the yeast, which has been dubbed Buttercup. In 2018, the company signed a deal with Archer-Daniels-Midland (ADM) to bring its dairy-free proteins to the food industry this year. (ADM happens to be one of the holdings in our dividend growth investing portfolio.)
3D printing appears to be finally emerging from a niche technology to a mainstream manufacturing process in everything from rockets to dentistry. Its use in the development and process of making alternative proteins isn’t surprising, though it remains to be seen whether it will be a fringe technique or experience widespread use in the next few years. At least one analyst at Lux Research is bearish on the whole thing, concluding, “Given that 3D printing of plant-based meats is essentially a niche within a niche, we do not recommend that clients engage with this space.” One could also dismiss Aleph Farms and its space-based experiment as more gimmick than game-changer. And research into developing full-on DNA 3D printers is intriguing but also in its early stages, with at least one company called Cambrian Genomics meeting an early demise with its owner’s death at 31. At this point, best to order a 3D-printed pizza and sit this one out on the sidelines.
Here at Nanalyze, we hold the lion's share of our investing dollars in a portfolio of 30 dividend growth stocks. Find out which ones in the Quantigence Dividend Growth Investing report freely available to Nanalyze Premium subscribers.